SHANGHAI HI SILICON TECHNOLOGY CO., LTD.
SHANGHAI HI SILICON TECHNOLOGY CO., LTD.

Titanium Diboride: Objective Comparison and Brand Recommendation Case of Well-Known Chinese Brands

Table of Content [Hide]

    HiSiaddi is an innovative foreign trade service provider driven by dual engines of technology transformation and foreign trade services, with a "1+2+3+4=1" service system and access to titanium diboride sourced from multiple well-known original manufacturers.

    As a foreign trade enterprise with R&D capabilities, HiSiaddi has repeatedly inspected titanium diboride brand enterprises through technical transformation cooperation with manufacturers, holding objective and in-depth understanding of different brands. Therefore, it frequently analyzes various titanium diboride manufacturers for customers to help them select matching products. The following is a recommendation case.

    For more comparative analysis of brands and models, please contact HiSiaddi customer service.

    Case: HiSiaddi Conducts Neutral Horizontal Evaluation of Domestic Top Titanium Diboride Brands to Support Accurate Model Selection and Procurement Implementation for a High-End Coating Enterprise in Switzerland

    I. Project Background: Swiss Mid-to-High-End Customer Faces Roadblocks in Localized Model Selection; Domestic Manufacturers Only Promote Own Products and Avoid Highlighting Competitor Advantages

    Swiss Coating AG is located in the Zurich High-Tech Industrial Park, a leading European enterprise specializing in mid-to-high-end precision coating and power device sputtering targets. Its products are mass-supplied to ABB Switzerland and Infineon European branches, focusing on metallization coating of IGBT chips and wear-resistant coatings for high-end CNC cutting tools, with an annual procurement volume of 88 tons of high-purity titanium diboride. It has long imported electronic-grade titanium diboride powder from Germany, with raw materials complying with EU REACH, SCIP and automotive-grade RoHS control. Rigid indicators include TiB₂ purity ≥99.5%, free titanium <0.2%, total oxygen ≤0.45wt%, single heavy metal impurities <8ppm and D50=2.2~2.7μm. Formulas are filed with the Swiss Federal Institute for Materials Science and Technology, prohibiting arbitrary large-scale modification of production formulas, qualifying it as a high-standard high-end raw material purchaser.

    Driven by successive price hikes of local European raw materials, extended ocean shipping cycles and tight production capacity of German original manufacturers, the client planned domestic substitution and independently contacted five top domestic titanium diboride manufacturers including Dandong Baode Boride, Shandong Hu Yuan New Materials, Hunan Huawei Jingcheng, Xi’an OZ Materials and Zhengzhou Gaoke Boron Materials to request samples and product brochures. Sales teams of the five domestic factories abide by industry rules and refrain from maliciously slandering competitors’ products, yet constrained by enterprise performance targets, they fully prioritize promoting their own flagship models and deliberately avoid objectively elaborating competitor product strengths and segmented applicable scenarios:

    · Baode Boride mainly promotes self-developed high-purity target powder, without mentioning Shandong Hu Yuan’s advantages in mass production stability and cost control;

    · Shandong Hu Yuan focuses on introducing large-scale mass production capacity, without highlighting Hunan Huawei Jingcheng’s unique strengths of customized ultra-fine powder for small-particle-size targets;

    · All other manufacturers adopt a unified statement that "our factory’s products are compatible with all types of targets and structural ceramics", deliberately blurring performance differences of various brand models across three scenarios: mass-produced targets, small-batch R&D and high-temperature structural ceramics.

    The client received a total of 9 titanium diboride samples from five manufacturers and encountered successive issues during independent small trials: poor slurry dispersion of partial powder, excessive sintering pores and coating pinhole defects. Its R&D team lacks familiarity with synthesis routes and process differences of domestic various brands, unable to distinguish adaptation boundaries of grades, resulting in two and a half months of stagnant model selection while the downstream ABB order stocking deadline approached. Finally, the client fully entrusted HiSiaddi, as a neutral third party, to horizontally decompose full-range product parameters, strengths, weaknesses and applicable scenarios of the five major brands and screen matching grades combined with end-demand requirements.

    II. HiSiaddi Objectively Analyzes Five Top Domestic Titanium Diboride Brands and Flagship Models (Neutral Listing of Strengths, Weaknesses and Applicable Fields)

    Combined with each manufacturer’s synthesis processes (self-propagating / carbothermal reduction / high-purity gas phase synthesis), factory internal control indicators, downstream implementation cases and impurity control capabilities, HiSiaddi’s material technical team broke free from manufacturers’ marketing rhetoric and objectively analyzed five mainstream brands from eight dimensions: purity, oxygen content, particle size range, impurities, sintering performance, minimum order quantity, pricing and applicable products.

    1. Dandong Baode Boride (Domestic Established Titanium Diboride Leader, Supported by Boride Research Institute Technology)

    Flagship models: BD-T01 electronic target high-purity powder, BD-G03 high-temperature structural ceramic powder Strengths: Laboratory technology transformation; BD-T01 features stable total oxygen of 0.40%~0.44%, no oxidized impurity phases via XRD testing, free titanium ≤0.16%, matching imported European raw materials with high sintered density, suitable for high-end IGBT sputtering targets. Original full-process closed inert atmosphere synthesis delivers industry-leading trace impurity control. Weaknesses: High unit price for high-end T01 grade; minimum mass production order quantity ≥1 ton, with 8~12 days delivery cycle for small-batch R&D samples. G03 industrial powder contains excessive impurities and cannot be used for semiconductor coating.

    2. Shandong Hu Yuan New Materials (Shandong Specialized, Refined & Innovative Enterprise, Benchmark for Large-Scale Mass Production with Full Industrial Chain Support)

    Flagship models: HY-E high-purity mass-produced target powder, HY-C general wear-resistant ceramic powder Strengths: Automated continuous production line with annual titanium diboride output exceeding 300 tons. HY-E features narrow particle size distribution and minimal batch fluctuation, delivering extremely strong supply stability for hundred-ton large orders with prominent cost advantages for bulk procurement, suitable for economical mass production of automotive electronic control targets. Self-owned upstream raw material supporting system enables traceable raw material sources. Weaknesses: Insufficient flexibility for customized ultra-fine particle sizes; limited production capacity for D50<1.8μm small-particle-size powder, unsuitable for small-batch special R&D raw materials.

    3. Hunan Huawei Jingcheng (Specialized Enterprise for Ultra-Fine High-Purity Customization, Research-Oriented Manufacturer)

    Flagship models: HW-S ultra-fine customized powder, HW-M mid-to-high-end precision ceramic powder Strengths: Full ceramic-lined crushing and classification processes enable precise customization of arbitrary particle sizes within D50=1.0~3.0μm, with alkali metals K/Na controlled within 1ppm, specializing in small-batch high-end R&D targets and aerospace special ceramics. Weaknesses: Small mass production capacity with long delivery cycles for single orders over 5 tons; unit price of large-batch raw materials higher than mass-produced grades of Baode and Hu Yuan.

    4. Xi’an OZ Materials (Supported by Northwestern Polytechnical University Materials Laboratory, Military Supporting Background)

    Flagship models: XZ-T target-specialized titanium diboride, XZ-J metallurgical sintering powder Strengths: Excellent powder density performance with outstanding anti-cracking performance during hot-pressing sintering, suitable for thick-film high-temperature targets and heavy-duty wear-resistant cutting tools. Weaknesses: High powder specific surface area prone to agglomeration in oil-based casting slurry, poor compatibility with the client’s original low-solid-content slurry formula.

    5. Zhengzhou Gaoke Boron Materials (Mid-Tier Powder Manufacturer in Segmented Market, Cost-Effective Precision Ceramic Raw Materials)

    Flagship models: ZG-M mid-tier precision powder, ZG-D industrial welding rod raw material Strengths: Mature carbothermal reduction process with high cost performance of mid-tier grades, suitable for general mechanical wear-resistant ceramics and aluminum electrolytic cell lining. Weaknesses: General total oxygen content >0.65% with excessive heavy metal impurities, failing to meet automotive-grade semiconductor raw material thresholds and unfit for chip coating targets.

    III. Select 2 Brands and 3 Customized Sub-Grades Combined with Swiss Client Product Demand

    The client’s products fall into two major segments: mass-produced IGBT automotive coating targets (69 tons per year) + small-batch special R&D cutting tool coating targets (19 tons per year), with rigid powder indicators locked to automotive-grade high-purity standards. HiSiaddi directly eliminated Zhengzhou Gaoke (substandard indicators), Xi’an OZ (slurry adaptation defects) and Hunan Huawei Jingcheng (insufficient mass delivery capacity), finally confirming two mid-to-high-end brands Dandong Baode Boride and Shandong Hu Yuan New Materials with three segmented sub-grades implemented in separate scenarios:

    1. Dandong Baode BD-T01 (high-end flagship target raw material): Physical and chemical indicators infinitely close to original German titanium diboride used by the client, perfectly matching filed original casting and sintering formulas, serving as primary raw material for mass production of high-end IGBT power chip coating, accounting for 42 tons of the 69-ton annual mass procurement volume.

    2. Shandong Hu Yuan HY-E (economical mass production alternative material): All indicators meet automotive-grade standards with lower procurement costs, used for the client’s mid-to-low-end economical electronic control targets to share the remaining 27-ton mass order and reduce overall raw material procurement costs.

    3. Customized modified Dandong Baode BD-T01-S (special R&D ultra-fine grade): Particle size fine-tuned to D50=2.3μm based on BD-T01, exclusively for small-batch R&D of the client’s special cutting tool coatings, covering all 19 tons of annual R&D raw material procurement.

    IV. Phased Sample Verification and Full-Year Procurement Order Mass Implementation

    1. Small Sample Testing Stage (5kg vacuum aluminum foil packaging per grade): HiSiaddi coordinated both manufacturers to issue English COA quality inspection forms and EU compliant SDS documents uniformly. Samples were air-freighted to Swiss laboratories for full reliability testing of slurry, sintering and coating. All three grades passed full Swiss automotive performance acceptance, while eliminated samples from other brands presented pores, pinholes and other defects and were formally removed from the procurement list.

    2. Pilot Mass Production Stage (500kg per single grade): The client ran continuous mass production on the production line for 15 days, with target coating defect rate equivalent to original German raw materials, reducing localized procurement costs by 32.8% compared with imports.

    3. Annual Long-Term Agreement Implementation: The client finalized an 88-ton full-year procurement contract, scheduled for production in 5 batches with HiSiaddi coordinating production scheduling, factory outgoing quality inspection, export customs declaration and REACH compliance filing. All batches passed customs clearance smoothly and arrived at Swiss warehouses.

    V. Project Review and Long-Term Business Expansion

    1. Industry Pain Points

    Sales teams of domestic titanium diboride manufacturers prioritize promoting their own products constrained by performance assessments. Due to competitive concerns within the industry, they will not actively objectively introduce competitors’ strengths even if rival products possess unique advantages in segmented fields. Formulas of mid-to-high-end European and American target raw material customers are filed with local institutions, prohibiting large-scale process modification. Lacking understanding of domestic various brand processes and grades, customers may easily select incorrect grades relying solely on single manufacturer promotions, resulting in mass production scrap losses.

    2. Core Value of HiSiaddi

    As a neutral third-party foreign trade service provider unbound by interests of single manufacturers, HiSiaddi conducts horizontal full-dimensional evaluation of mainstream domestic brands based on end production process demand of customers, breaking information barriers between manufacturers and relying on objective model selection services to resolve model selection blind spots of high-end overseas customers, binding exclusive long-term procurement cooperation.

    3. Extension of Long-Term Cooperation

    After project implementation, the client renewed a 102-ton annual long-term titanium diboride order in the following year, and simultaneously fully entrusted HiSiaddi with exclusive agency for Chinese model selection, sample testing and compliant export of special powders including zirconium diboride and niobium carbide. Relying on this case, HiSiaddi successfully secured titanium diboride procurement orders from two high-end coating enterprises in Denmark and Norway.

    For more comparative analysis of brands and models, please contact HiSiaddi customer service.


    References
    We use cookies to optimise and personalise your experience, but you can choose to opt out of non-essential cookies.
    To find out more, read our Privacy Policy
    Reject All
    Accept All